• 38 Posts
  • 939 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 9th, 2023

help-circle







  • Voting has always been about whether you agree or not with an opinion

    No, that is absolutely false. Before Reddit’s Eternal September, voting was used as a way to signal quality content and it pretty much was followed by a good majority of the people.

    Right-wing as in neo-nazi? I would not join a community in that server.

    And this is precisely what people are talking about here. You might not see that way, but tankies are extremists. There are people that don’t want to join any conversation there, and therefore this is why they want alternatives.

    Think of what?

    It makes they think "what is so bad about this comment that it really warrants the downvote.

    Does not voting against your post not count as compliance?

    I didn’t ask you to remove the downvote. I asked you only to explain your reasoning, which is now quite clearly faulty.




  • Do you think I can just keep the last comment in mind or something?

    YES! It’s not like votes are worth anything here, but one of the reasons that voting mechanisms become completely useless as a way to signal quality conversations is when people blindly upvote/downvote everything just because they don’t like what is being said. People that do what you are doing end up showing more about themselves than about the one posting the comment that you didn’t like.

    As does the drive to try and split communities

    Would you feel so defensive about it if the communities were being hosted in a right-wing instance?

    Why would tagging people who downvoted a post prevent a pile-on of downvotes?

    Because it makes people think about what about the comment they are downvoting, instead of reflexively clicking on a button.

    vote->get called-out seems to fit ‘blackmail’

    It does not fit at all. I’m not trying to get anything out of you for my own benefit, and I am not doing it to submit you into compliance.