That’s right, get piped Youtube!
Ironic that this comes from reddit and is watermarked with reddit ad
I stole it from imgur.
Next time stamp an imgur label on it, like a traveller’s suitcase full of stickers of places it’s been.
deleted by creator
And this is why we hate watermarks. Shit looks tacky
To the YouTube apologists in this thread, where were you when there were no ads?
For years YouTube allowed content creators to post videos without any ability to monetize, and they harvested your data and sold it while they did.
Where were you then you hypocrites?
Now, YouTube provides the worst possible solution to monetisation, removes existing affordable ad free tiers, and sells your data without sharing the proceeds to creators.
You’re bootlickers. Get out of your armchair and actually help content creators instead of giving your cash to a company who syphons off most of it to further abuse you and creators you like.
For years YouTube allowed content creators to post videos without any ability to monetize, and they harvested your data and sold it while they did.
Let me preface this by saying fuck YouTube. But they were losing money on YouTube during this time on purpose. They weren’t actually making enough money to run the site by selling data alone. Their long game was to starve out any potential competition because they knew nobody else had enough capital to just give the same product away for free. The plan worked, hence their monopoly on Internet video hosting. Ever since they’ve been introducing more and more shitty limitations, ads, and anti consumer bullshit simply because they can. Google’s monopolies really need to be broken up. Let me end this by saying fuck YouTube, and fuck Google, too.
Which is what pisses me off. If Google is so money hungry here, why not raise the rates on advertisers instead? Not like these multibillion dollar companies like Coke, Pepsi, Apple, etc have anywhere else to go for advertising online with a large audience exposure. If people have to watch ads, keep it minimal on the viewer and maximize it on the advertisers.
According to the principle of enshittification:
Here is how platforms die: first, they are good to their users; then they abuse their users to make things better for their business customers; finally, they abuse those business customers to claw back all the value for themselves. Then, they die.
So currently we are on step 2: abusing their users. When they start abusing the business customers as you suggest, they will be on step 3 and one step closer to death.
Here’s the thing. Cory Doctorow is almost 100% spot on with the first 3 things. The last one, however, is pure copium. Those platforms died, yes, but they died in a very different era of the internet.
There was a time where people jumped ship with abandon and routinely visited cool, new websites every other week. This is the time that I like to call the “big liquid” internet. The internet was popular, yes, but every day people spent a little more time on it than on t.v. and other kinds of popular entertainment - in other words, popular but still growing. Websites like Digg, if they fucked up and just straight up ruined user experience, would die as a result of enshittification. The internet was cutthroat, and the quality of your service mattered. If people didn’t like your website, they were going to leave.
We don’t live in that era of the internet anymore. We’re in the era of the “big solid” internet. People don’t go to “new websites” anymore. They don’t jump platforms. They don’t abandon and adopt. If they’re kids, they go where their friends are - probably Twitter/X or TikTok. Maybe reddit. If they’re old users they’re on instagram and Facebook. It doesn’t really matter how bad those platforms get, because the quality of the service is not really important. It’s that they don’t have anywhere else to go or anything else to do.
There is no more exploration or adventure to the internet as we once understood it. That’s why Google has waited so fucking long to enshittify their most popular product: it’s because you’re locked in. There is no competition, because the competition died or was killed off a long time ago.
I agree with a slight caveat. You’re right that the internet of today is more forgiving of platforms that enshittify. “If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face – forever.” -literally 1984, where the boot is advertising and the human face is consumers’ attention.
So we may be stuck at phase 3 for a while, where the consumers and the businesses are getting screwed over by internet platforms. But although the technological environment is changing more slowly, it’s still changing and “with strange aeons even death may die”. When the platforms inevitably die, enshittification will be part of the analysis why.
Of course in the meantime the internet platforms make money for one set of people, and other people’s lives are made crappier because of it.
I used to have a pixel art tut on YouTube, about 30k views. as they kept changing their terms as the time went by, in my disfavor, and in the user’s disfavor, I deleted the video. fuck them.
Havent done too much research but I’d suggest uploading that tut to a YouTube alternative, be it peertube, rumble, or kick
Good for you. You should consider moving your content to Nebula or the likes. It helps people like me support you without propping up a malicious middleman like Google.
What even is the first part of this? Where were people? They were using the service while it hemorrhaged money. Now they’ve moved past that to increasing revenue. That period was never going to last. Where’s the hypocrisy? What’s the uniform position these people have according to you?
It’s also rich how you assume everyone has enough to make meaningful contributions to every creator they watch on their own.
I would go a different direction and say that if, beyond the excessive amount, you just can’t stand that ads exist on the platform then you are entitled and think free content is your right.
I wasn’t talking about giving YouTube money, I was talking about giving creators money. Suddenly we must support the racket to give creators money according to many. I ask: where were they when there was no racket? Certainly not giving to creators. So we must only pay creators if we must also pay the content host? What nonsense.
YouTube has had ads for longer than I’ve been using it. They introduced it in 2007 from a quick google search. I started using chrome in 2009, and Adblock extensions not too long after.
I’ve been here the whole time and I’ve known that ads were a way to monetize the video, but I blocked them because I don’t like ads. For a while it just seemed like Google didn’t care. I just did it because I could and there was no alternative. When they released premium , I went that route. I use and depend on the service for a lot , so I don’t mind kicking them some funds.
But please do continue expecting something for free despite the fact you have an option to watch it for free with ads or to pay for premium because that’s how it always was 🙄
So you’re saying you refuse to watch YouTube? I’m not quite sure what you’re statement here is. If it’s “fuck youtube for the bad things it’s done, I want ad free content and I won’t pay” then we live in different ideologies for sure.
I think content creators should get paid
Yes the only way to pay content creators is via YouTube. What a keen insight. We’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of ideas!
For many of them, yes, the only way is via YouTube. Some of them have patreons, and I use that too. Not all do.
Does reddit watermark their images now like tiktok?
when i used the default app it was just a bar at the bottom saying where and who posted it
and some people put reddit watermarks on their memes
though it might be something new since ive stopped using reddit
I wouldn’t call it a watermark but yeah, they have been for a good while if you export it from the app.
I assume based on this image.
Yes, they do with the official app, I think you could turn it off though.
I can’t hear over all the adfree yt content I watch via newpipe and freetube
As God intended.
I just deleted Chrome and switched back to Firefox
You’re not the only one I’ve seen. It’s pretty entertaining that Google’s decision to neuter adblock plugins in Chrome then deploying anti-adblock measures on Youtube is pushing folks off Chrome.
Welcome back to Firefox. :)
Now that I’m back I really don’t know why I left.
I’m kind of confused, I’m getting the anti-adblock on Firefox too?
It’s on Firefox too.
I use revance on my phone just because I also used Vanced before it was taken down, works like a charm as well, with background play, Sponsorblock and everything
Edit: update URL
This site that you linked is sketchy. Revanced isn’t supposed to give pre-made apk files. That’s how they get away from takedowns
Edit- this is the real link. https://revanced.app
Never download premade apks
Thanks for noticing, you are ofc right, I got the wrong link somehow. I updated the link in my original post
revanced.app allows you to download their apk, am I missing something?
I used Vanced and tried ReVanced after that. The app patches would fail even though I made sure that all settings and other conditions were exactly as the setup and troubleshooting guides recommended and eventually I just gave up trying.
With NewPipe and SmartTube, all of the things the OP and you mentioned just work out of the box and changing features and other settings is as easy as in for example Firefox…
Try downloading the APK (in the recommended version) from apkmirror. Patching the installed app also never worked for me
Thanks for the suggestion but I’m good with my current setup heh. I’ll probably give it a try if NewPipe or SmartTube become crap for some reason 🤷
also Libretube is a better looking app + more true to the normal youtube app imo. plus when you disable the Piped proxy it’s always reliable
Personally how the app looks isn’t much of a priority unless it’s so bad that it hurts usability and maybe 7/10 times I tried to play a video in Libretube it would either hang for at least a minute or fail to play at all.
That’s just not an acceptable tradeoff for looking slightly better than NextPipe that’s near-flawless on my phone and SmartTube that’s near-flawless on my tv, neither of which is bad-looking IMO 🤷
that’s completely acceptable. i like when apps integrate with my Monet color theming and I’ve never had issues loading video after i turned off the Piped proxy, basically just turning it into NewPipe with a different look. In my experience, don’t turn that on unless you have a specific reason to. It leads to video loading issues just like you found.
Some things I like about LibreTube:
- The PiP functionally works better than in Newpipe
- I can see the likes and dislikes of comments and expand the thread to see more comments
- Swipe gestures to enter and exit fullscreen just like on the normal YT app
- I can view a content creators content by Livestream, Short, normal video etc. for some reason shorts just don’t show up in Newpipe
- SponsorBlock integrated. I am aware there is Newpipe x SponsorBlock
If NewPipe has a way to add the above functionality, I’ll gladly try it again!
Ngl, I’ve been considering just taking the plunge (no pun intended, it is a good one though) and just exporting all my subscriptions and watching everything on piped.video. that way I get a curated feed of content I enjoy (which is what I already like about lemmy), and be able to curb my youtube shorts addiction into the ground with it.
it’s just better even as UI. you can pick all the settings:
- set default video resolution
- autoplay
- allow/skip ads
- allow/skip sponsor messages
- play audio only
- hide suggested vidya/comments/description (toggle)
- dark mode
- no tracking
- no email required for account
- toggle shorts on/off
- should homepage be trending or subscription feed?
I mean what the hell else can you want?
I’ve done this. I use Piped on Desktop and Phone and use SmartTube on my Chromecast
I did this with freetube
deleted by creator
Sponsorblock supports Invidious. Go into the Sponsorblock settings under Misc and enable it. You might have to add an instance’s URL (on the same settings page).
In your Invidious local settings, there should be a “Feed Menu” setting. This allows you to choose which tabs appear on your local homepage. (If you have an account, then these settings are for your account and should persistent anywhere you log in.) You should be able to choose “Popular” or “Trending” as one or more of your tabs.
For FreeTube, you can copy the link from your browser (from YouTube or any Invidious instances at least) and paste it into FreeTube’s search bar, and it will go directly to the desired video. If you use Firefox, Privacy Redirect has a setting (under Advanced Settings --> Invidious) to redirect all YouTube requests to FreeTube. You would have to turn the plugin off to search, then turn it on when you want to use it.
FreeTube currently has two sections “Most Popular” and “Trending” that fetch content from creators I haven’t subscribed to.
Hope this helps.
A New Pipe? 😀
I believe newpipe uses invidious? Libretube uses youtube piped.
NewPipe and LibreTube both use the Piped API, unless you’re smart like me and disable it because the public instances are incredibly unstable.
Let me get all the hate.
No ads= no income for the YouTube content creators. “But you can support them directly” But do you? I guess 0.1% of viewers buy merch or donate or are patreo subscribers. How do you want to get good content on YouTube without anyone paying for it? Can’t be mad if the content is getting worse and the sponsor messages are getting more and more.
In the past, I didn’t block ads on YouTube for the reason you describe. The amount has increased so much over the last couple of years that I had to start - multiple unskippable ads before a video are just not acceptable.
Instead I subscribe to Patreons (which I swap around every couple of weeks depending on who I watch the most).
Sucks to suck. I refuse to be advertised at.
Most YT creators are getting most of their money from the sponsors they promote. YT ads suck for revenue unless you’re gigantic and with how yt will demonetize you for literally anything it’s too unreliable too be sustainable.
I only started when a 1:00 video had 0:30 unskippable ads at the beginning and another 0:30 at the end. If the ad is more than the video why bother watching the ads.
I’ve also had moments were I wanted to see 1 specific point for a couple seconds, but just have to watch unskippable ads before I can scroll to the part I wanted to check (like a tutorial part).
get newpiped YouTube!
I’ve been using revanced and I love it.
Got a link?
Well their real business model is making YouTube shitty with ads, and then offering YouTube Premium as the solution. Nice, you artificially create a problem, then provide a subscription plan.
Yep, that’s all companies mill you these days. Do something stupid to piss off your user base, and then instead of fix it for free… sell the solution. Then they wonder why stock prices drop, and people move to other competing services.
ADGUARD FOR DESKTOP! LOAD IT WITH THE ANTI-ADBLOCK KILLER USER SCRIPT!
Sorry! I have Tourette’s syndrome…I can’t help but scream random shit, usually software names at the top of my lungs
REPORT THE WEBSITE AS “detected adguard” IF YOUTUBE SHOWS THE WARNING AGAIN!
FREETUBE!
I ran into revance issues, the solution turned out to be you need to use the recommended version of YouTube as the base… not the latest
